Invidual Rights Vs Public Order Essay

There is no right that is more fiercely guarded than of the Freedom of Speech. The right to be heard and the right to speak freely is an important aspect of every government that is accorded such a primacy in the hierarchy of rights. The reason for this is that every government is primarily established for the benefit of the people and when that government, for one reason or another, fails in its solemn obligation the citizens have the Freedom of Speech to try to rectify the situation. It is this hallmark of democracy which makes it the ideal form of government.

As such, it is important to remember that while there are individual rights there are also responsibilities that come along with it such as the maintenance of peace and order. Public order, therefore, is something that can be seen to protect the rights of others and in certain cases it can be perceived as a disadvantage because it requires the execution of certain acts or the meeting of certain criteria to ensure the safety of others. No right, even those granted by the constitution, is absolute.

Every right that a person is granted is always subject to certain limitations and restrictions. In protecting these rights, there are often considerations of public order that are detrimental because they render it nearly impossible to carry out the tasks necessary for the protection of individual rights such as free speech and assembly. This is perhaps the single most challenging job of the Justice system as it is tasked with not only the arduous job of ensuring that individual rights are upheld but also that public order be maintained.

There is no sacrifice and compromise when it comes to this and oftentimes justice is delayed or even frustrated in an effort to comply with public order policies such as due process, probable cause and public order. Oftentimes, there is a balancing test that is employed to make sure that the needs are served but this occasionally falls short and in these cases public order becomes more of a hindrance in the realization of a real democracy.

Read also  My Favourite Author – Ayn Rand

More Essays

  • Privacy Rights and Press Freedom

    Oftentimes, the Court is confronted with the issue: Which right demands greater protection, the right to privacy or the freedom of expression or of the press? The so called balancing-of-interest doctrine gives the court the prerogative which right demands greater protection.  In Lagunzad v. Sotto vda. De...

  • Individual Rights and Public Order

    Individual rights are those rights we have that allow us to exercise our freedoms granted by the Bill of Rights. The Bill of Rights, originally drafted in 1789 by James Madison, came into effect in 1791 (Wikipedia 2007). The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not construe to deny or...

  • Health & Social Care

    Ai Identify four key pieces of Legislation and Codes of Practice relating to handling information in social care setting. 1). Data Protection Act 1998 – Gives rights to individuals in respect of personal data held about them. It also seeks to protect individuals with regard to the processing of personal...

  • Political Theory

    Envy Test—The theory that the division of resources is actually equal if and only if one person does not prefer someone else's portion of the wealth to his own. That means that if everyone in society is ahppy with what they have as compared to what everyone else has then the society passes the envy test....

  • Principles for Implementin Duty of Care in Health and Social Care

    1.1Explain what it means to have a duty of care in own work role: A duty of care is a legal obligation imposed on any individual working within the care sector that they adhere to a standard of reasonable care whilst performing any acts that could foreseeable harm others. It is my responsibility...

  • My Favourite Author – Ayn Rand

    "We are fast approaching the stage of the ultimate inversion: the stage where the government is free to do anything it pleases, while the citizens may act only by permission; which is the stage of the darkest periods of human history, the stage of rule by brute force." Ayn Rand, who lived from 1905 to 1982,...

  • A Case Study on Animal Testing

    Imagine a world where humans are taken to laboratories and tested on in a callous manner. A world where people are injected with harsh drugs and chemicals that physically and mentally harm their bodies and their life. If this scenario does not sound acceptable to act upon humans, then it surely cannot be...

  • The Cure for Ills of Democracy

    Democracy is always named and used in the liberal discursive process. But if we refer to history, democracy of these days is not the same as democracy decades ago. Thus, it is important that democracy is understood as an evolution and not as a static concept. Similarly it is necessary to understand...

  • Withholding Information

    It is frequently advisable for those in positions of authority in government to withhold information from general public Some information the public has the right to know while other information is better to be withheld. There are plenty of reasons why it is better not revealing information. Withholding...

  • Duty of Care in Own Work Role

    Having a duty of care in your own work role is a requirement to avoid negligence and harm and the safeguarding of children under your care. Young children are very venerable and are almost entirely dependent on adults to care for them in ways that help to protect them from harm. This could be physically or...

Read also  Person Centred Approaches