Education in the United States Essay

India has made large strides in educating its population of more than a billion people, yet a lot remains to be done. It is commonplace now that education is both intrinsically valuable and also instrumental for economic well-being, and this is true for individuals and entire nations. No country in the world has been able to develop without the spread of mass education. An educated population is a prerequisite for take-off into high economic growth. Table 1 in the appendix shows literacy rates for India as a whole and by sex. It also shows the decadal rates of change from 1901 to the present.

2 Literacy rates have increased for both males and females, and though the latter continues to lag behind the former, there has been a narrowing of the male-female gap in literacy: from 24. 8% in 1991 to 21. 7% in 2001. In 2001, the absolute number of illiterates declined historically for the first time by nearly 32 million. In terms of state-wise performance, Kerala continues to occupy first rank as it has done historically; on the other hand, densely populated states like Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and Bihar are yet to overcome their educational inertia. 3

The average figures for India as a whole hide a great deal of variation among states. Table 2 in the appendix provides literacy rates for states for the years 1991 and 2001, for the population as a whole, by sex and also provides the decadal rate of change. In 2001, Kerala, Maharashtra and Himachal Pradesh had more than 75% of their population of 7+ years literate. On the other hand, even in 2001, less than half of Bihar’s population of seven years and above was literate with female literacy rate only 33. 6%. In terms of zones, states in the South and West outperform states in the North and East.

2. Primary Education Primary education refers to the education of children between the ages 6-11 years (grades 1-5). Universalization of Primary Education (UPE) is a constitutional provision in India and there has been a steady expansion in the spread of primary education since Indian independence in 1947. The Indian educational system is the second largest in the world after China. In 2001-02, there were nearly 0. 66 million primary schools in India 1 This study has been undertaken as part of the United Nations Millennium Development Goals Project.

2 Before the 1991 census, only those belonging to the age-group 0-4 years were excluded from the population in order to compute literacy rates and the basis of the computation was the entire population. From the 1991 census onward, literacy rates were computed based on the population aged 7+ years and above. 3 In Bihar, Nagaland and Manipur as well as Delhi and Chandigarh, the absolute number of illiterates has increased in the 1990s. 4 providing access to 84% of habitations with a primary school located within a distance of one kilometer.

Between 1997 and 2002, the gross primary school enrolment rate4 for India was 111 for males and 92 for females. The net primary school enrolment rate5 on the other hand was only 78 for males and 64 for females. The net primary school attendance rate between 1999 and 2002 was 79 for males and 73 for females. However, of the children who entered primary school, only 68% reached grade 5 between 1995 and 1999 (UNICEF, 2004). Table 3 provides data on gross primary school enrolments by sex between 1950-51 and 2001-2002.

As can be seen from the table there has been a steady increase in the numbers of boys and girls attending primary school over time. In Table 4, state-wise enrolment of boys and girls as a percentage of their age-group is provided for 1997-1998. Girls’ enrolment has been steadily increasing over time and in 2001-02, nearly 45% of girls in the age-group 6-11 were enrolled in school. These statistics are heartening because at least until the 1990s, one of the most dismal aspects of India’s education system was the large percentage of the population in the younger age groups that were out of school.

Socio-economic disparities Despite the strong constitutional backing for the provision of primary education in India6 and its expansion over time, the system is characterized not only by low achievements but also by large unevenness of achievements. Huge gaps remain between rural and urban areas, and the probability of getting any education at all sharply depends on gender, caste and income. Women, scheduled castes and tribes and the poor are faced with formidable barriers when it comes to getting basic education. Of the 200 million children in the age group 6-14, it is estimated that 59 million are out of school.

Read also  American Education Vs. the World

Of these 35 million are girls and 24 million are boys (Ministry of Human Development, GOI). Apart from socio-economic determinants, the educational infrastructure and the management and the governance of the educational system in India are far from efficient or sufficient. The government is the largest provider of education in India with only about 10% of primary schools owned by the private sector. 7 The quality of education provided by the public education system is low which translates into low educational abilities even for those who are able to complete primary education cycle.

Moreover, there is a lot of ‘waste’ in the educational system with dropout rates as high as 40% for the country as a whole and in some Indian states, they are as high as 75%. Though the number of primary 4 Gross primary school enrolment rate is computed as the number of children enrolled in primary school regardless of age divided by the population of that age group. 5 Net primary school enrolment rate is computed as the number of children in that age group enrolled in primary school divided by the population of that age group. 6 In 2002, the Supreme Court of India decreed that free primary education was a constitutional right.

7 Around 3% of private schools are aided by the government, which makes government intervention in the education sector even greater. 5 schools in the country increased, more than 1 lakh8 habitations still do not have access to a primary school within a distance of one kilometer. Teacher-pupil ratios are inadequate: less than 2 teachers are available in rural areas to teach a class size of around 100 students. Teacher motivation and teaching incentives are also very weak. India perhaps has the highest rate of teacher truancy in the world. Poverty and Education.

Empirical evidence strongly shows that, both at the level of the household as well as at the level of the country, there is a positive relationship between income (and wealth) and educational attainment. More income simply means more resources available to spend on the acquisition of education. With more than 250 million people in India living on less than a $1 a day, poverty remains a major barrier to educational access. Although education is provided ‘free’ by the government, the cost of uniforms, textbooks and transportation costs are beyond the reach of many households (Tilak, 2004).

Added to these direct costs are the indirect (opportunity) costs of wage/domestic labor which children perform and the costs of acquiring education become considerable for households. Graphs 1 and 2 in the appendix show simple regressions of literacy rates for sixteen states against state poverty rates and state per capita income for 2001. As is expected, literacy rates decline with poverty and rise with per capita incomes. State per capita incomes seem to explain literacy rates better than poverty rates.

Filmer and Pritchett (2001) using Demographic Health Survey data for India find that the gap in enrolment between the highest and the lowest wealth class is as much as 52 percentage points. Gupta (2003) using the 52nd round of National Sample Survey data finds that the percentage of people who have completed five years of schooling declines as one descends consumption deciles. In the lowest consumption decile, the proportion of people who have not completed the primary school cycle is greater than 80%. 9 While poverty status and income class are strong determinants of who goes to school and for how long, they do not make up the whole story.

Indian states of Kerala and Himachal Pradesh even with fewer resources at their disposal have been able to achieve much better educational and health outcomes compared to rich states such as Punjab and Haryana in India. This is true even when we look at cross-country outcomes. For example, Sri Lanka and Botswana do much better in education and health terms than would be predicted based on their level of resources; the Latin American countries do much worse given their resources (Mehrotra and Jolly, 1998). 8 One lakh is equal to 100,000. 9.

Read also  Education Policy

These graphs are meant to be illustrative of the association between resources and education and do not claim any direction of causality. The relationship between resources and educational attainment is bidirectional. The poor cannot afford schooling. With little human capital, the opportunities to escape persistent poverty are very restricted and the poor can be trapped in a low education, low income vicious cycle across generations. A large literature has analyzed both theoretically and empirically persistence of poverty inter-generationally due to lack of resources to invest in education.

More Essays

  • American Education Vs. the World

    United States public schools were regarded as some of the best public schools in the world up to the 1970's. Compared to the educational development of Asian and European students, American students and the education system are ranked embarrassingly low. "In a 2003 study conducted by UNICEF that took the...

  • Mexican Educational System

    The Mexican Constitution, established in 1917, outlined the necessity for public education, creating a definitive forum for addressing the educational needs of the country at the beginning of the century (Althaus 1). Though the Constitution addressed the issue of education, it did not provide a directive...

  • Literacy Rates

    Literacy Rate in India – To know development in a society, Literacy is another proper indicator of economic development. For purpose of census, a person in age limit of seven and above, who can both write and read with understanding in any of the language is considered as a literate in India. As per 2001...

  • Education Policy

    Security, quality education, access to healthcare, prospects of a reasonable job on merit and sound economy are the ingredients to be provided by the state to its citizens to run the state and the society smoothly. Growth of successful nations is denoted particularly to the education. There was a time when...

  • Local and State Education Agencies

    Dear Colleagues, The purpose of this document is to provide a stand-alone guide for local and state education agencies faced with the task of designing a new or upgrading an existing automated student information system. While based on a chapter from the Student Data Handbook for Elementary, Secondary,...

  • Hindi

    Hindi (हिन्दी), or more precisely Modern Standard Hindi (मानक हिन्दी), is a standardised and Sanskritised register of the Hindustani language. Hindustani is the native language of people living in Delhi, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh and parts of Rajasthan Hindi is one of the...

  • Floods in India

    India, being a peninsular country and surrounded by the Arabian Sea, Indian Ocean and the Bay of Bengal, is quite prone to flood. As per the Geological Survey of India (GSI), the major flood prone areas of India cover almost 12.5% area of the country. Every year, flood, the most common disaster in India...

  • Primary Education

    According to the Kenyan government, education is "A long term objective to provide basic quality education to enhance Kenyans ability to preserve and utilize the environment for productive and sustainable livelihoods, to develop quality of the human race; to realize the universal access to education and...

  • Educational in Cambodia

    Education is very important means to train and build up human resources for development of each country and it is also important for development of child as person. However, educational system in Cambodia has suffered too much during Khmer Rouge Regime from 1975 to 1979. After that period, the government...

  • Goal Statement

    I have planned on becoming a teacher for years. After receiving my own education, I look forward to sharing my knowledge with my students. In the past I have taught classes in creative writing, instrumental music, sailing, various sciences, and religious education, allowing me to experience the interactions...

Education in the United States Essay

When people go to work, they get a salary. When they go to school, they receive an award. However, at work you get paid for being present, and there is no evaluation of the work you have done. While at school you get an award for the quality of work you have done with specific evaluation of each particular participant. Many authors discuss about the necessity of evaluation in the school system. They use grades as their reference point, and they argue over its importance in the system. I refer to two articles: “The Farce called ‘Grading’,” and “Grades and Self-Esteem.

” The author of each article has a different view about grades in the American educational system. Is that necessary to have a controversy about grading students? I believe that students deserve a grade for their work. The author, Arthur E. Lean, in his article, “The Farce called ‘Grading’ ” objected to the idea of grading students. He believed that they used grades the system scholar in order to reward and punish students (p. 132). He stated that the tendency of grading was to humiliate and make the less intelligent student pay for his or her incapacity to learn even if it wasn’t his or her fault (p.132).

To emphasize his point of view about the unimportance of grades in the system scholar, he declared, “In spite of the staggering amount of incontrovertible evidence that grading not only does not accomplish its purpose, but in realty inhibits and injures the educative process, we obstinately continue with this perverted practice (p. 132). ” In my opinion, Arthur’s view that they should eliminate grading in academic evaluation is wrong. The author based his own experience to make a generalization about the procedure of grading.

He explained his experience as a teacher when he was called to participate in an evaluation of a student work in order to establish a standard for evaluation (p. 131). Because there were different results for the same paper, Arthur believed that the grading system was unfair. I cannot share the idea of unfairness of grading with Arthur. I believe that every teacher has his own method of teaching. Consequently, every teacher will judge a paper according to this method of teaching.

I think that only the teacher who has taught a student can really give a fair grade to the student because the student is only following the instruction of the teacher. I cannot support the generalization approach made by the author when he points out, “Every person who has ever gone to school can cite numerous instances of unfairness and injustice caused by grading system and practices, but for some strange reason we seem it to assume it to be necessary and intrinsic to the process of formal education. ” As a student myself, I have not marked with an unfair grade.

I think that when a teacher dispenses a course, he expects to see on his student’s paper the lesson he has taught. The teacher can easily see if a student is following his method, so Arthur ignores the fact that every teacher has his own style. He is completely wrong when he uses the example of the student’s paper to convince the readers’ opinion. Unlike Arthur, Randy Moore presents a different view of grading in his article “Grades and Self-Esteem. ” He believes that grades are important because we can judge the quality of work of a student (136).

Read also  Csp Reflection

Therefore, he accuses the supporter of self-esteem who gives grades to protect the student’s self-esteem. He states, “To avoid feeling bad, these teachers lower their standards so that virtually all students meet them, regardless of the student’ s performance. ” He explains that the cause of failure in the quality work in America is due to the objective of the “school’s building self-esteem instead of education (136). Moore refutes the idea of giving grades without merit. He states, “I argue that self-esteem is earned and that schools, despite their good intentions, cannot dispense it as a packaged handout.

” He proves in that statement that he is in favor of grading students, and he supports high standards to evaluate students in order to prepare better students for the success in their work On the other hand, Moore in his article explains the practice of unfairness in the grading method of the American education without supporting it. For instance, he criticizes the disciples of self-esteem who attempt to make courses “nonjudgmental”(136). Such practice tends to join the idea of Arthur who believes that giving a grade is unfair and incalculable (131).

Moore is correct when he says, “We cheat students out of a quality education and give parents false hopes about their child’s intellectual skills. ” I think that giving a grade to a student that doesn’t deserve it helps neither the student nor society. My own experience has shown me that grades are important in any system of education. As a student, I expect to receive a grade for any work that I have done. When I get a grade, I have an idea of how much I understand the class. I believe that if schools were running without giving grades to students, many students would not bother to attend.

Each author has a different view about grades in the American educational system. Arthur believes that they should eliminate grades because it is unfair and unworkable. Moore supports the idea of using higher standards to evaluate students. In this topic, he is in favor of grading. Both authors present arguments to prove their points, but I’m unable to endorse Arthur’s point of view because for myself, grades help me determine the degree of knowledge that I acquire. Therefore, I support the point of view of Moore who believes that students will improve if we require them to exceed higher standards.

More Essays

  • Western Parenting Vs. Eastern Parenting

    Chua feels that the traditional Chinese way of parenting is the only way if you want a successful child. If you ask almost any other Western American, it sounds more like the parent has become a dictator and their children are nothing but peasants that aren't allowed to fail otherwise they are shamed and...

  • Straight a Student

    There are many students that get straight A's in school, but there are also many that don't. Most students may think that there is no way for them to receive straight A's; that they are just not smart enough. Sometimes you don't have to be the impertinent or the most forsaken one to receive straight A's,...

  • Online Viewing of Grades

    Introduction Most college schools here in the Philippines have an online grade viewing/inquiry system, especially in metro manila. The trend of using this kind of system is growing fast, and reaching even schools in provinces. What is an online grade viewing system you ask? This type of system is a...

  • Review of Related Literatures and Studies

    The proponents reviewed several related studies and literature. This was done to clarify different ideas from other studies and literature. Relevant ideas of some students who developed some software were also reviewed. Related Literature The proponents understand that the program to be made without...

  • Discuss About Failure

    Q: ‘The word failure should never be used in education.' Discuss. "Failure is not the end of the journey." was an impactful phrase that Steve Jobs once said in his most eulogised moment of wit. I would dare to say that ‘failure' is not a foreign word to anyone in the world and to the large majority, it is...

  • High School Goals

    High School to some is the best part of their lives and to others is the worst part of their life. As for me I believe high school is just about setting goals and achieving them. Personally, I set up three important and motivating yet perceivable individual goals to get me through high school. My First Goal...

  • Common Core Standards

    Much like the runways of Paris with its changing fashion trends, the world of education follows trends as well. Educators cringe when they hear "No Child Left Behind" some ten years beyond its advent. Now, the phrases "Common Core" and "Student Learning Objectives" have teachers seeing red. However, despite...

  • Weak Curriculum Vs. Inadequate Instruction

    Curriculum and inadequate instruction both have their pros and cons when it comes to the decision-making process of what works best to achieve higher level learning among students. Curriculum mainly focuses on the knowledge and skills that are important to learn where as instruction is what learning will be...

  • Glue Out of Cigarette Filter and Acetone

    This chapter includes the past related literature / studies and researches, articles and some information gathered to guide in this study or research. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE According to (Marvilde, 1981), Classroom absence is a major factor responsible for falling standard in school education system...

  • Early Intervention in the First Grade

    Early intervention are programs that are designed for young children who are below grade three or those children falling in the age brackets of three years and eight years. These programs are usually designed to help children who seem to lag behind their peers at school in such areas as reading skills which...

Read also  School Speech